For more information, please see our Arthur wasn't planned until the development of rdr2. Little moments like the one above are worth discussing. I would like to imagine that it's too painful to recall memories of Arthur. There are, to my knowledge, no supernatural occurances in RDR1 apart from possibly the Stranger, and even he might be explained by misfiring bullets and a network of intelligence contacts. so he didint want to rat them out. So I was kinda curious too why Arthur wasn't mentioned. I already feel satisfied. Perhaps, one of the reasons, Ross comes back to John and kills him, is because of Uncle. ^ Yeah. TL;DR - John doesn't mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) He's ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back. TL;DR In RDR1, John doesnt mention Arthur because 1) it hurts him to think of him, 2) hes ashamed that Arthur saved his family, and 3) he said not to look back. Only one I remember from rdr1 was bill and Dutch. What Did John Do With Arthur'S Hat? - Bliss Tulle The past is behind us now. Of course, the IRL reason is that Arthur wasn't created until RDR2. There is even an appearance of the green mask that starts all the craziness from Undead Nightmare in a fence's shop in RDR2, connecting the two parts of what appears to be the same timeline with physical evidence. He didn't get mentioned the same way Saddie wasn't mentioned, or the native american dude, or Micah Bell, Pearson, Lenny, Joshua, Karen, etc My point is: There's no particular reason for him not being mentioned. off topic, but correct me if im wrong, was landon ricketts a outlaw before he came a vigilante ? Privacy Policy. RDR1 was about Marston beyotching the whole game about those who did him wrong. As others gave stated there us no mention of Arthur. Uncategorized. In rdr1, Arthur Morgan was never mentioned. The closest RDR was to mentioning Arthur was when John speaks to Bonnie saying a "friend" aka Arthur helped him escape the gang life. Here are my thoughts: We know for a fact that time travel and aliens and a whole host of weird shit exists in this universe, and this theory just relies on us seeing an alternate reality with at least one extra person in the Van der Linde gang, so it's kind of less far fetched than all that other stuff. Question: Are There Any Secrets In The Beaver Hollow Camp I wish they were developed a lot more, particularly in terms of their relationship with John. Which he does say at point I'm the ending of rdr2 talking to strangers. Especially since even then, he doesn't like talking about his past, let alone dwell on the details. He he saved us!, ABIGAIL: Well, yes. Morgan isn't low level, pretty sure he's even Dutch's right hand man. By using GTAForums.com, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Arthur betrayed him by failing to trust him and putting his faith in him. Existing user? TL;DR - In RDR1, John doesn't mention Arthur because 1) it hurts him to think of him, 2) he's ashamed that Arthur saved his family, and 3) he said not to look back. The past is behind us now. Witness Protection. By 1911, he's not mentioned at all, which does make sense in some ways because, as said, he went down in history as one of a group and anything he did was thought to have been done by the gang as a whole. For more information, please see our P.S: of course we know that they didn't think on this new character when they created RDR1, but let's theorize just based on the storyline's perspective and not the limitations or the guessing that R* had back in 2010 vs now. To dress as the outlaw Arthur Morgan, you will want a Grizzly Hat, Long Sleeve Shirt, Canvas Pants, Suspenders, Scarfs, Cowboy Gun Belt, Toy Pistol, and Cowboy Boots. And maybe Arthur is hiding as well (obviously somewhere else and not on the ranch), and Ross caught wind of that. or what im hoping is that if they are alive marston was on good terms with everybody else. Great summary, no need to preorder this game now. Presumably, John hadnt had anything to do with Arthur for something like 5-10 years by the time of RDR1. EDIT: To all the people saying "Arthur wasn't created until RDR2, that's why," you're missing the point. GTANet.com 2001-2023. But your father dont like to talk about him. ^ Yeah, thats very basically right. Not all the new gang members need to die in RDR II. Note: This is ONLY to be used to report spam, advertising, and problematic (harassment, fighting, or rude) posts. . TL;DR John doesnt mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) Hes ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back. Then he left the gang because of how Dutch and Others Went Crazy And Uncontrollable. There are clever retconned reasons for it. rdr2 pc teleport mod In the same vein, why is Arthur never mentioned in RDR? This part of my theory is based largely two key things: That there are different timelines presented in the Red Dead story, and that one of these timelines is packed with supernatural elements while the other is mostly mundane. Required fields are marked *. how to save arthur morgan from tuberculosis As many have pointed out, John states in RDR1 that the gang never went as far west as New Austin and implies that he is not familiar with the place either. There are no official ways to travel to Mexico. I came up with a theory on what would happen if Mr. Downes didn't spit on our Boah., I just finished Far Cry 5 and my only question is Why? I think Arthur will be like an older brother to John, never turn his back on him and will go on to live a peaceful life on a ranch somewhere in the end and was never mentioned because john had no resentment towards Arthur warranting redemption unlike the other gang members. and our Answer (1 of 5): When you finish the game, you can explore the world as John Marston. The closest RDR was to mentioning Arthur was when John speaks to Bonnie saying a "friend" aka Arthur helped him escape the gang life. burger_mike and, saintsrow, By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Call Us Today! Well actually its a retcon as said above but in epilogue John says that they (John and his family) left this part of their lifes behind. (Looks at me) Do you, John?, JOHN: (pause) No. and our im thinking either. John says, "Imma curb stomp that rat!" Arthurs last dying efforts (in my playthrough) were to save the Marstons, and among his last words were to not look back.. The Blackwater Massacre was an infamous and violent gunfight involving the Van der Linde gang, the Blackwater Police Department, the Pinkerton National Detective Agency and supposedly the famous gunslinger Landon Ricketts, which took place in the town of Blackwater in May 1899 during a robbery on a nearby ferry. For most of the past 10 years, Jimmerson has been behind bars, yet never given the opportunity to tell his side of the story at trial. Why is Arthur not mentioned in RDR1? Maybe the gang would've survive if he wasn't sick?. Companion theory: RDR2 and Undead Nightmare take place in the same timeline, separate from RDR1. For Arthur? or maybe. Red Dead Redemption: Game of the Year Edition - amazon.com The REAL Reason Why Arthur Morgan Is NEVER Mentioned In The - YouTube By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Rockstar needs to do RDR3 and tell us what in the mother of fuck happend before and during Black Water. Also, why is Arthur not mentioned in rdr1? "Nobody talks about it," Holmes said. During the mission " Political Realities in Armadillo " John tells the Marshal " You know, I hear you speak and suddenly, I'm reminded of how some of the people I respected the most in my life had a problem with authority ". By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Luckily for Arthur, in 1899 there's no TV where he can can be heard yelling "Where's Ah Munneh???" 2023 GAMESPOT, A FANDOM COMPANY. The REAL Reason Why Arthur Morgan Is NEVER Mentioned In The First Red Dead Redemption Game!Cheap GTA 5 Shark Cards \u0026 More Games: https://www.g2a.com/r/mrbossftwIn todays Red Dead Redemption 2 video - I'll be explaining why I believe Arthur Morgan was never mentioned in the first Red Dead Redemption game!SOURCE:https://gtaforums.com/topic/909282-speculation-topic-why-arthur-is-not-mentioned-in-rdr1/#commentsMy Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/MrBossFTWMy Snapchat:https://www.snapchat.com/add/MrBossSnapsMy Twitter: https://twitter.com/#!/mrbossftwMy Instagram:http://instagram.com/jamesrosshudginsHope you enjoyed this video! Alienous. I especially like seeing Arthur Morgans interactions with the gang. It doesn't have to be. John is well aware of this as well. Whats amazing to me is that, even now, I still catch little moments I havent seen yet. Sorry . Best Work Writer's Discussion 2016 [The "I Love Karen Daniels" fanfic]. This little scene took place today at Beechers Hope. add domain users to local administrators group cmd; smart cash loan first convenience bank; quincy fl police department officers; david gresham son of joy davidman Any theories? They addressed it through story and character in many subtle ways to discover, rather than a single throwaway line. Why do they never mention Arthur Morgan in RDR1? GTA Online New Bonuses for 27th April 2023 - The Last Dose Hard Mode Event is here alongside rewards for completing the missions and extra payouts, the Issi Rally is back, and more! 22 How To Rob Bank Rdr2 Ultimate Guide 04/2023 Playing as Arthur Morgan, the player is cast into the very end of the wild west. Jack and Abigail sit in the living room. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Why is so necessary to remove all realism from the game? But that's just me linking stuff from my own eyes. Some of them probably hanged. He tells people that he was in a gang with Dutch, Bill and Javier, they left him for dead in a botched robbery and he left the gang. Do you think RDR2 was a good RDR1 prequel? | ResetEra With the new year fast approaching and many new game releases on the horizon, its time to look ahead at some of the biggest upcoming games of 2022. Everyone knows that. The one he wears in the first game, in particular. But your father dont like to talk about him. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Should you kill the O'Driscoll in the barn? I follow him and *greet* him before he steps outside. Isgho Votre ducation notre priorit . The ending we get with John is the one that would have happened if Arthur had been around to save his ass and teach him the importance of family. MARKUS. Maybe The Strange Man, telling John that "he has forgotten so many important people", is a hint on John pretending he doesn't know who or where Uncle and Arthur (and possibly other gang members) are. That something is redemption for all of his gang members, and Arthur is his most important. Red Dead Redemption 2; All Activity; Home ; Red Dead ; Red Dead Redemption 2 [Speculation Topic] Why Arthur is not mentioned in RDR1? ), JOHN: You know, I did a little saving you myself., JOHN: (pointedly) Youre my family, boy., (Jack leaves. Sign In . Arthur morgan never mentioned in rdr1 : r/reddeadredemption Content posted in this community. section 116, row b staples center (Looks at me) Do you, John?, JOHN: (pause) No. RDR2, on the other hand, is littered with ghosts, ghost trains, aliens, giants and other weird things right alongside the main story. Even in 1907, he's barely mentioned at all, so history forgot about him. EDIT: To all the people saying Arthur wasnt created until RDR2, thats why, you're missing the point. The point is, the writers didnt lazily ignore the fact that John didnt mention Arthur in RDR1. So, they probably weren't expecting to return to it. We would have seen a sequel earlier if that was the case. I go back to the living room and *greet* Abigail, who is still sewing on the sofa), JOHN: (irritated) Why would you say that?, ABIGAIL: (awkward) Its true, aint it?, JOHN: (difficult) Look I can talk about him it just hurts is all., I think the retconned reason (the story reason) that John doesnt talk about Arthur in RDR1 is because he misses him like a brother, but also because hes kinda ashamed of the fact that Arthur saved his ass on more than one occasion, and ultimately saved his wife and son. Arthur Morgan is a fictional character and the main playable protagonist of the 2018 video game Red Dead Redemption 2. The gang is composed by dozens and dozens of people so why would he be mentioned in particular? I follow him and *greet* him before he steps outside. Because his character was probably created after RDR1 was completed. how to save arthur morgan from tuberculosis - hrts.com.mx On RDR1 that should have been part 2 because Author was raised by Dutch but he really didn't believe him anymore and Micah either. I clarified that this is the STORY reason, not the IRL reason. 1907 Roleplay REDM Hiring Admins, Serious Roleplay, Active Development. Most of what Arthur did was considered an action of the gang as a whole, not just him. Plus, based on John's dealings in RDR with the remaining old gang members, generally didn't go so well. Anyone playing RDR1 after RDR2 is going to be very confused whenever John speaks about his past. Don't warn me again for Red Dead Redemption 2. See you guys in the next one! The point is, the writers didnt lazily ignore the fact that John didnt mention Arthur in RDR1. Any mention of Arthur in RDR1? (end game spoilers) Cookie Notice That something is redemption for all of his gang members, and Arthur is his most important. /r/RedDeadRedemption - A subreddit dedicated to Red Dead Redemption & Red Dead Redemption 2, developed by Rockstar Games, the creators behind the Grand Theft Auto series. haven't played rdr in forever. You could have just predicted the whole plot of RDR2. He lassos Arthur, and the mission instructions at the bottom of the screen read, "Find a curb," but while he's looking all over town to try to find a curb in 1899, the mission timer times out, and Arthur gets away, starting a new underground life. he made it out and shacked up in Bolivia. Arthur gave them the money to flee and start over, which turned out to be money wasted because their new life prospecting in the Tundra failed. You are reading about how to rob bank rdr2. All Rights Reserved. Ultimately the decision does not matter. EDIT: To all the people saying "Arthur wasn't created until RDR2, that's why," you're missing the point. For more information, please see our he figured if the government didint mention them then he wasent going to bring them up. Blackwater Massacre | Red Dead Wiki | Fandom Cheap GTA 5 Shark Cards & More Games: https://www.g2a.com/r/mrbos. why is arthur not mentioned in rdr1 - khushboocatering.com Valve Corporation. Arthur gave them the money to flee and start over, which turned out to be money wasted because their new life prospecting in the Tundra failed. We also know that alternate timelines have been explored in the Red Dead universe. So he killed both John and Uncle, knowing that John isn't someone he can trust with this. It's because he doesn't exist in RDR1's timeline. they all died. There is a conversation between Abigail and Jack where Jack brings up that he has memories of the family's time with the Van Der Linde gang but doesn't remember much due to him still being a toddler back then. Mr Van der Linde - Chapter 6 - dutchvanwinkle - Red Dead Redemption This is over.". Would he have helped John and his family? Home; Service. Only one I remember from rdr1 was bill and Dutch. They had to return to America broke, taking odd jobs in Strawberry and then Pronghorn Ranch. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Here's why Arthur's not mentioned in RDR1 In this case, Arthur abandons John in order to return to the gangs burning camp. gosh who also wants a RDR1 remaster now??lol. [Speculation Topic] Why Arthur is not mentioned in RDR1?